Can I use cloud solutions that store personal data in the USA?

In most cases, no.

OC 11 does not prohibit the processing of personal data outside CERN Member States, including in the United States. Rather, it establishes a combination of requirements that are generally easier to satisfy where processing takes place in CERN Member States and/or in jurisdictions providing data protection standards comparable to those laid down in the GDPR.

In particular:

  • § 92 requires appropriate safeguards, including effective data subject rights and legal remedies, before personal data is transferred to an External entitiy.
  • § 97 requires that CERN may engage processors only where they provide sufficient guarantees to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures so that the processing meets the requirements of OC 11
  • § 98 establishes specific contractual obligations for processors, broadly aligned with those under Article 28(3) GDPR. In particular, § 98.7 also requires the processor to respect CERN’s privileges and immunities.

Taken together, these provisions do not prohibit processing in third countries. However, compliance with OC 11 is generally easier to demonstrate when processing takes place in CERN Member States or in jurisdictions that provide comparable data protection standards and are willing to recognise CERN’s privileges and immunities.

Additional CERN Requirements

To answer this question fully, data protection requirements are not the only consideration. CERN’s procurement and contractual requirements must also be taken into account.

CERN’s standard contractual conditions generally require that personal data processed on CERN’s behalf remains within CERN Member and Associate Member States. This helps ensure not only the fair return to these states, but also that personal data remains subject to CERN’s legal framework, including its privileges and immunities.

As a result, cloud services that store or process personal data outside CERN Member States, including in the United States, are generally not permitted unless a specific assessment has been carried out and explicit authorisation has been obtained.

Important Clarification

Some countries, including the United States under certain frameworks, may be recognised as providing an adequate levels of data protection comparable to European standards.

However, GDPR adequacy alone is not sufficient for CERN. CERN’s requirements extend beyond general data protection considerations and include institutional and contractual obligations, notably those relating to CERN’s privileges and immunities.

What does this mean in practice?

  • Prefer cloud solutions that keep personal data within CERN Member States.
  • Do not transfer personal data outside CERN Member States without prior assessment and explicit authorisation.
  • Do not assume that a service is acceptable simply because it complies with GDPR or other EU data protection requirements.